Friday, May 23, 2025

Better or Worse?

I was doing an unofficial (and short) photo walk a couple of days ago, wandering around Highland, IL while my wife was getting a haircut.  I ended up with several photos I like, so it was an hour (and 1.5 miles) well spent.

One of my photo finds was this payphone.  It is on a corner of a former convenience store, which is now an open lot.  I presume it still works, but didn't check.

The first photo was my original concept:  the emptiness, the old technology hanging around.  After that, I got the bright idea to reshoot, catching a car in the background:  the modern world passing by the archaic phone.  I was even able to get a little blur on the car to accentuate the movement.



 So, I fell in love with the second concept, so deep and meaningful.  I posted it to one of my photo sites, where the consensus was "lose the car".  So I went back and looked again, and am convinced the original concept was better (the top photo, no-car).


What do you think?

No comments: