I can't decide if AI is an evil treat to mankind, a useful tool, or just a silly toy. I suspect it is a bit of all 3, though it seems to be advancing at a frightening pace.
Anyway, for a giggle (and based on some recent discussions in a photo group) I decided to ask ChatGPT to analyse one of my photos. My actual prompt was "Is this photo any good?"
And the ChatGPT response, do you agree/disagree?
- - -
This photo is quite compelling — especially from an artistic and documentary perspective. Here’s a breakdown of its strengths and suggestions for improvement depending on your goal:
✅ What's Working:
1. Strong Concept / Storytelling:
-
The contrast between the natural cornfield in the foreground and the rising suburban development behind it is visually and thematically powerful.
-
It evokes commentary on land use, urban sprawl, or the changing American landscape — almost like a modern-day "manifest destiny" in reverse.
2. Black & White Choice:
-
Stripping color out enhances the contrast and texture, and pushes the viewer to focus on form, light, and subject.
-
It also gives the image a timeless or slightly documentary feel, reminiscent of photojournalism.
3. Composition:
-
Nice horizontal balance — the horizon line and cloud-filled sky provide depth, while the rows of corn act as a textured lead-in to the homes.
🔧 Suggestions for Improvement (Optional):
1. Stronger Subject Isolation or Focus:
-
You might consider experimenting with deeper contrast or selective sharpening to emphasize the tension between nature and construction more clearly.
-
A version with selective color (e.g., green field + B&W homes) could also be striking if done tastefully.
2. Crop or Alignment:
-
If you're aiming for symmetry or impact, a slight crop to center the most unfinished or prominent house might tighten the composition.
3. Contextual Caption:
-
This photo begs for a caption or title — it could turn it from a simple landscape into a narrative image. Something like:
"Where the cornfield ends."
or
"Growth or erasure?"
📷 Is It “Good”?
If your aim is fine art, social commentary, or environmental storytelling — this is absolutely a strong photo.
If you're aiming for traditional landscape beauty, it may come across as too stark — but that's a matter of taste, not quality.
No comments:
Post a Comment